


Our butterscotch pie is made with our all butter pastry dough crust filled with homemade our butterscotch custard. We make our custard with butter and sugar and cook until caramelized. Then we add our heavy cream to create a delicious butterscotch custard. Then we top the pie with our freshly whipped vanilla bean cream and hand chopped Heath Bars.
All pies are boxed in our beautiful pink pie box tied with our silver foil pink satin ribbon. Gift enclosure cards & candles are also available.
Due to the delicateness of this pie, we are unable to ship.
*Due to the small size of our kitchen not all pies featured are available year round. We change out our pie flavors every three to four months, so each pie flavor will have their months of availability separated by seasons. The current season we are in will be the pies available.
You can now have Gwendolyn's elegant swan as a beautiful top to your cake for birthdays, weddings and anniversaires. She sits ontop of her golden cake stand, adorned with a jeweled necklace to make any celebration shine.
This beautiful handmade Red Velvet Cake ornament is a replica of the cake we make in the bakeries. A soft blush pink with rosettes and a little sparkle cover the cake. Handmade in Poland, Gwendolyn's ornaments are the perfect keepsake or perfect gift.
Gwendolyn's Cake Bake Shop has partnered with Jean Charles Boisset (JCB) of the Boisset Wine Family to showcase their Rosé Sparkling Wine from the Burgundy valley in France. The color and exceptional quality of this Crémant embodies the style, sophistication and elegance that The Cake Bake Shop is known for. From the vineyards of France all the way to your table. Celebrate life! Available for purchase in both shops and for delivery within the metro area of Indianapolis only.
Celebrate with Gwendolyn's Rosé Bubbles! Grown, bottled & labeled in France. Served & sold exclusivily in her shops, also available for local shipping.